2005 AL MVP - Who should it be and why?

[GonzoStyle]

So it's Arod's 20 steals and the fact that he brings a glove to the game that makes him the MVP? If that's the case, then why didn't Ozzie Smith win every year?

Because Ozzie smith never hit 50 home runs, what a stupid comparison. You say just because he brings a glove like its a small thing, Ortiz plays half a game, he doesnt play the field and thats huge. So the small edge he has on A Rod evens out and then some, for ortiz to win he'd have to be far and away much better but he's not. Arod is a complete package of hitting, running. and fielding while Ortiz is just one of those, although no ones arguing a great one.