2005 AL MVP - Who should it be and why?

[GonzoStyle]

dh is not a position, its a spot in the line up. Naturally its not his fault he doesnt get playing time for that fact that there is a dh spot in the AL but thats my opinion in the matter and you seem to be making this a red sox/yankees thing which its not. Like I said 20 times already, I wouldnt be upset at all if Ortiz won, its just my opinion that he's not so much better than A Rod because for what advantage ortiz has in offense, a rod makes up for with his glove. Its as if I am saying that for the simple reason hes a dh he doesnt deserve to win which is exactly what I am not saying. My Point is that both teams are very similar in that their pitching wasnt great all year and both teams have great supporting players so to me its not like a bonds where they are the only thing on the team that makes them a contender.