Your Turn To Play God - a hypothetical situation

[OAS]

If you are God and play by all the rules and teachings of God, it is B. All the nicey nice guys die and come to God's kingdom where they have been promised a better life for all eternity. The scumbag lives his pittiful life on earth, eventually dies and is not allowed to enter your kingdom because of his actions on earth. He is dammed to an eternal suffering in Hell. So who is our new member here that just got dammed for all time in Hell?