You Make The Call

[Sir O]

In my league's scoring...I'd take Garner's consistent 1,800+ total yards and 10 TDs over Dillon's 1,600 total yards and 10 TDs.

Seems like a no-brainer to me.

Their averages are close over the last 4 years.

Garner 1718 yds, 7.5 TD
Dillon 1558 yds, 8.25 TD

What separates them, IMO, is three things. 1) Dillon is 3 years younger, 2) Dillon is more consistent year to year (look at Garner's 2001 numbers), 3) Garner's knees are banged up (he's already questionable for the season opener).