01-25-2005, 05:28 PM
Looking at the whole of their career both offensively and deffensively, the only catcher who holds a candle to Piazza (and is better in my opinion) is Ivan Rodriguez.
Arpi saying that Piazza's not in the top 10 means he'd be including Gary Carter and Posada based on his "rah rah rah for the home team" rather than actual baseball knowledge. Piazza was also better than Fisk
Arpi saying that Piazza's not in the top 10 means he'd be including Gary Carter and Posada based on his "rah rah rah for the home team" rather than actual baseball knowledge. Piazza was also better than Fisk